HomeDigital MinistryWebsites4 Things You're Doing Wrong With Your Church Website

4 Things You’re Doing Wrong With Your Church Website


Your church website is very important. For many people, it is the front door to your church, the first impression that they get. Likely your website is also a resource to your members, a place to keep everyone up-to-date and promote events and such.

If you are in charge of your church’s website then you’ve got a lot on your plate. I’m sure the last thing you want is someone telling you what you’re doing wrong. Well, that’s exactly what I’m going to do. However, my hope is that these suggestions will not add more work to your already busy schedule. Instead, my goal is to give you some focus and help improve your effectiveness.

Here are four things your church might be doing wrong with its church website:

1. You’re Not Telling Stories

When creating content, churches have a tendency to focus on the things, that is, the features if you will. We do this all the time with church announcements and events: “This thing is happening at such and such time in this location. We’ll be doing this and that and YOU SHOULD COME!” We do a great job presenting the when and where, but we often neglect the why.

If your website is full of “when” and “where” information only, you are missing a great opportunity to share your church’s story with the “why” behind the information. Also, don’t just focus on telling the church’s story, be sure to include stories from those in the congregation. This will help visitors make an emotional connection with the message your church is delivering.

2. You Don’t Have a Target Audience

When you create content for your church website, make sure that you have an audience in mind. Defining a target audience for your church website can be very difficult since some of our content is directed to members while some is directed to visitors.

My recommendation is to make a clear definition between the content you write for the church members and the content you write for visitors. Both can exist on the same site, you just need to have a clear content strategy that helps you to make the distinction.

When you define your target audience for your content, get as detailed as you can. Create a few different character profiles that you can write to. Answer questions like: What is their family like? How much money do they make? What are their goals and aspirations? What are they hoping to get from the church’s website? Etc.

Answer these questions with information from real people in your congregation. Then, write to these character profiles and that will help your content to connect with your audience.

3. You’re Not Tracking Visitor Behavior

If you are not already tracking visitor analytics, this is something you should setup right away and it’s pretty easy. If you have not already done so, create a Google Analytics account for your church. If you are using a CMS like WordPress you can install a plugin to connect to your new Google Analytics (I recommend Monster Insights for WordPress).

Once your Google Analytics account is set up it, will begin tracking website visitor data. From this, you can gain insight into how users are interacting with the site. Review this data regularly to see what pages on your site are most popular and how people are engaging with your site. This will help you to know where to focus your efforts.

4. You’re Not Being Consistent

Consistency is super important for content creators! If you update and add content to your website in spurts, you could be hurting the site’s credibility. Consistency and routine help build trust in your audience.

I would recommend coming up with a regular schedule for adding content to your website so that your audience will know what to expect. This might mean cutting down on the number things that you post online. It is better to post shorter or fewer articles on a consistent basis than to post large updates infrequently.

If you have found any of this helpful or have further advice from how you’ve increased the effectiveness of your church website, please leave a comment below.

Tanner Moushey
Tanner Mousheyhttps://missionlab.dev
Specializing in custom solutions, Tanner's work has pushed WordPress to its limits. He's even helped pioneer its future as a core contributor to WordPress’ source code and popular tools like Restrict Content Pro and BuddyPress. Tanner is the CEO at Mission Lab where he leads a team building church products like Study Church and serving mission driven organizations.


  1. Tanner,

    Great post and points! Specifically, I like point number one and I have the most fun consulting churches on that very point. There is so much a church can accomplish by telling their story well to a potential first-time guest. Presenting a clear identity, compelling brand, and using candid photography is really critical to do so. When carried out well, I have seen that to be a huge difference maker for a church to actually convert someone into a first-time guest.

  2. Tanner, these are all very good points. Often times, I talk with churches that want a website because they are “supposed to have a website” but they don’t have a plan or put intentionality behind it. When implemented properly, these four areas can turn an “existing” church website into a thriving church website.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Featured Posts


3 Guiding Principles for Worship Pastors in the Church Today

Worship pastors should serve and foster participation, not entertain spectators. They need to think like a theologian, labor like an artist, and shepherd like a pastor. To keep these priorities in mind, here are 3 guiding principles to lead by.

How to Keep Your Hybrid Church Healthy for Years Ahead

Today's episode will tackle the topic: How To Keep Your Hybrid Church Healthy for Years Ahead. Kenny Jahng spends time with DJ Chuang for today's episode and talk through some of the relevant questions for digital ministry today. How do you make the online worship experience better? How can you better engage through small groups digitally? How can you clearly identify that your church provides digital ministry? Let's dive into today's conversation on the Church Online Podcast!

12 Best Video Apps for Creating Reels Videos

Video is the new black., especially for social media. You KNOW you have to start focusing on creating more videos. Which app should you use? Here's a list of the top apps for editing Reels videos, based on our experience.